How each approach reduces energy
An intermittent-holding unit uses a standard induction motor, a pump, a PLC and an accumulator. The pump supplies oil during motion, stops during a pressure hold and restarts when pressure falls below the set level. The PLC reads pressure and controls this cycle, so the unit needs neither a servo motor nor an inverter.
A servo-driven unit adjusts its drive to supply oil as demand changes. That makes it a natural comparison when pressure or flow must change continuously or fast response matters.
Which duty to assess first
Use the working cycle, not the motor type, to choose what to evaluate first.
Starting points
- Long clamping or pressure holds with low leakage: assess intermittent holding first
- Continuous, precise control of pressure, flow or speed: include servo and other supply options
- Very short holds: the saving may not justify a retrofit; measure before deciding
- Intermittent results depend on accumulator capacity and start/stop control
Compare on the same boundary
Record motion, holding and standby times plus energy over a representative shift. Then compare intermittent holding, servo and variable-displacement options using that same duty profile, including cycle time, energy, maintenance and purchase cost.
Results measured on different machines, outputs or measurement boundaries are not comparable. The same-boundary energy verification guide describes how to record a baseline and re-test.
Maintenance and power supply
Neither design is maintenance-free. Check the actual bill of materials, interfaces, ratings and approved spares rather than assuming one design will always be cheaper to repair.
A standard induction motor still needs a suitable supply, including voltage, frequency and phase conditions. A servo drive is not simply a conventional inverter. Check the site supply against the selected components and agree the protection configuration.
FAQ
Frequently asked questions
Our holds are short. Is intermittent holding still worth it?
A short hold can be assessed, but the saving may not justify the investment. No universal minimum holding ratio is established. Measure a representative shift and compare options on that duty profile.
Servo units also save energy. Why consider intermittent holding?
Choose by duty rather than assuming that a standard motor is always cheaper or more efficient. Long clamping holds are candidates for intermittent operation; continuous precision control calls for comparison with servo and other alternatives.
Is a standard motor immune to voltage fluctuation?
No. It still requires a suitable supply. Check site voltage, frequency, fluctuation range and protection against the selected motor and control components.